I dont see that in you. During the Easter weekend in April 2010, guards prevented Williams from choking to death on a cardboard toilet-paper tube he had shoved down his throat. Together they would compare notes and plan their next course of action before Smyth returned to the video room. It was during these short breaks, when Smyth disappeared behind the closed door, that hed consult with the police monitors who had been observing from the adjacent room. Smyth periodically left the interrogation room to get updates from the search teams, which provided him with more damning facts. And they are absolutely not considering these whatsoever," Dafoe said. We talked recently about, you know, the whole idea of any unusual sex acts of your history. . click here. Together they analyze the body language and behavior displayed in videos in the public interest. . Col. Williams also revealed to police in the interrogation that he suffered from chronic pain, a condition that his co-workers and old friends have returned to time and time again when they've been asked by reporters about any changes they observed. Why do you think these things happened? he asked. does Toyo Open Country H/Ts. [5], I know youre an intelligent person, and you probably dont need to hear this explanation, the detective said, stroking the colonels ego to win his favor. Theres a search warrant being executed at the residence in Tweed, and your vehicles have been seized, okay?. my wife, its been a dream for the better part of a year, so Im keen to get them what they need so they can leave her alone, the colonel stressed once again. The detective broke the cold silence . CSI officer couldve come in three, four days from now, did some swabs here, and he wouldve found your DNA and my DNA. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. Dafoe, who has a photo of Lloyd in her bedroom, said Smyth reached out to her after he saw her online petition and until then she hadn't thought about the investigator. Roberts said he once "cracked a guy from the Hells Angels because in his wallet were pictures of his dog and his dog was the most important thing in his life.". That civilization was known to overwhelm and assimilate entire other civilizations; in stating its intent the Borg collective always announced: Resistance is futile.. 13 years to the day that he was acquitted of the murders in Brentwood, Simpson was convicted of robbery and kidnapping and was later sentenced up to 33 years. No, Williams insisted, shaking his head slightly, his arms still folded tightly in front of his chest. Eventually he began to take breaks from his seat, leaning against the wall for long periods of time. The video showing the interrogation of convicted sex killer Russell Williams is a window into the way skilled investigators use psychology to extract confessions, experts say. Smyth then elicited more details of the four attacks, despite fumbling over the names of the two sexual assault victims and having to be reminded by their attacker. The detective, as though trying to land a big fish, continued to pace his efforts by offering his adversary some slack before tactfully reeling him in just a little bit more. That's why investigators will typically study up on their subject before entering the interrogation room, carefully reviewing the items found in police searches. Age: 43. He stared blankly ahead with his arms folded defensively as the officers words fell upon deaf ears. Shortly after this investigation started, they identified those tires as the same tires on your Pathfinder, said Detective-Sergeant Smyth. Retired OPP investigator Dave Perry said it is compelling to watch as Smyth calmly presses Williams on his links to the crimes. But I cant answer that question.. The interview continued for several hours, but Williams did not balk. He interjected his high-ranking military status strategically by adding, I guess the closest. Sometimes Williams walked in through unlocked doors. He could also smell a slight odour of decomposition, he said. I know youll take good care of sweet Rosie [their cat]. I know she loved you very muchshe told me so, again and again. Sgt. Jim Munsterman, Alicia Lampert and Bill Holmes. McClintic's confession on May 19, 2009, led police to focus their search efforts on an area north of Guelph. Let us never forget their bravery and . Then Williams took Lloyd to his silver-coloured 2001 Nissan Pathfinder, parked in a nearby field, and drove her to his cottage. 3 February, he dumped Lloyds body in the woods near Tweed. After another long pause, Williams sighed. Smyth has also taught forensic interviewing and forensic behavioural science at Toronto's Seneca College. [2] Modern police tactics are much more benign and non-adversarial. Okay, Williams responded with a firm nod. Thats the plan. Detective-Sergeant Jim Smyth began his career with the York Regional Police (in Ontario, Canada) in 1988 before joining the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) in 1997. At the time, he had murdered two young women by suffocation, beaten and tied up two of his neighbours before photographing them naked, and stolen about 500 items of lingerie and clothing from the closets of unsuspecting women. I was hoping not, said the man who was once called a shining bright star of the Canadian military. In Canada, once a person has been cautioned (advised of his/her right to remain silent), even if they choose to lawyer up, police can continue questioning the suspect before their lawyer is present. Colonel Russell Williams appears in a Belleville, Ont., courtroom on Oct. 7, 2010, as depicted by a sketch artist.Alex tavshunsky. The Behavior Panel is a non-partisan group, looking to educate and entertain the public with their interest and expertise in nonverbal communication, body language, deception detection, interrogation, and resistance to interrogation.Watch the Russell Williams full interrogation here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ndaaSxc1PPIThis behavior profiler group takes on the task of investigating the behavior behind the crime news that often forces us to think and feel the way we do. Contact Stephanie: stephanie.matteis@cbc.ca and @CBCsteph on Twitter. But for veteran crime writer and crusading editor J. Patrick OConnor, the factsor a lack of themdidnt add up. Over the next two hours, Williams repeatedly raped Comeau, beating her viciously if she resisted. Robin McKay Current Workplace. By continuing to use our site, you agree to our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy. 50-year-old Detective Sergeant Patrick 'the Dog' Smith from Cavan was a thorn in the side of the Republican movement. Would it surprise you to know that when the CSI officers were looking around her property that they identified a set of tires. [1][2][3][4] Smyth also discovered the remains of Tori Stafford.[5]. ?. The statement is a reminder that her good friend was "kidnapped, raped, tortured and murdered" by Williams and that the "disclosure of these details was a traumatic nightmare.". By day Williams commanded the largest military base in Canada; by night he stalked single women in their bedrooms. He did not know why he had targeted Marie-France from amongst all of her colleagues on the base and purposefully used his status as base commander to specifically access her personal information. 1:19. . By avoiding the tersely worded and scripted format that officers must read an accused upon arrest, this soft form can be presented in a more casual and less intimidating manner in order to avoid spooking a suspect into clamming up. Plus, special edition NP Platformed and First Reading newsletters and virtual events. Perry said you can see the growing discomfort registering on Williams' face as he is confronted with more and more damning evidence. Jim Smith interrogated the killer for six hours before handing the interview over to Det. At six feet two, Williamss tall and lean build dominated the smaller-framed officer. Your Pathfinders wheelbase width is very, very close to the width of the tires that were left in that field, Smyth said, his tone still very calm and calculating. During the brief roadside interrogation, officers saw that the tread of Williamss tires matched those found in the field. . . The bizarre case shocked the military and the country and became an international media sensation. I want you to see what I mean.. A much more formal letter of condolence had been sent to Mr. Comeau on official Office of the Wing Commander military stationery on December 1, 2009, written and signed in the capacity of Marie-Frances commanding officer. ., What they also do to try and identify the type of vehicle is they look at what they call the wheelbase width, the officer told him, explaining that various makes and models have different measurements. Jessica was a beautiful, gentle young woman. Use of this Website assumes acceptance of Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy | Accessibility, Published Friday, October 22, 2010 2:16PM EDT, Last Updated Saturday, May 19, 2012 3:00AM EDT, Taxpayers pick up cost of damage to Williams' home, Williams evidence should be destroyed, lawyer warns, After Williams trial, residents hold 'healing event', 'Sadosexual' killer Williams gets 2 life sentences, From the Archives: Fans celebrate Leafs 2004 playoff win, This globetrotter raises $300,000 for kids with disabilities, What you need to know about faded, peeling Ontario plates, CTV National News for Apr. So if you didnt take pictures, what would you have done with her? the investigator probed. He captured it all on video. Insp. But he plugged along relentlessly, without losing his footing.[7]. Okay, you want discretion, we need to have some honesty, okay? Lloyds ordeal continued until about 8:15 p.m., when Williams cracked her skull with a flashlight and strangled her with a piece of rope. Smyth then paused the interview for twenty-two minutes while officers obtained the samples from a fully compliant Colonel Williams, who also surrendered his BlackBerry and brown leather boots for forensic examination. Colonel Williams sniffled. Smyth played a key role in the Stafford case even before the interrogation of Williams. Williams spoke frankly and matter-of-factly, showing no emotion as he described how he had planned and carried out the rapes and murders. . It was a clear case of arson, and five people from Marlborough were duly convicted of the crime. . Get email updates from your favourite authors. Brent Snook, a forensic psychologist and professor at Memorial University, said Smyth's interview was highly professional and non-confrontational in nature. However, 15 of the 25 Orleans families whose homes were broken into reported the crimes to the Ottawa Police Department. Okay. Closed Captioning and Described Video is available for many CBC shows offered on CBC Gem. The PEACE model, for instance, is more open-ended with a softer approach while the Wicklander-Zulawski approach focuses on non-accusatory interviews. Theyd find a mother lode of explicit images on the devices, featuring all four of his victims, he assured Smyth. From that moment, Williams was under police surveillance. Media outlets praised Smyth for following his "hunch," though the detective shrugged it off, saying that the police had followed "hundreds of hunches" that hadn't yielded anything. Robin McKay has been working as a Detective Sergeant and Identity Crimes Unit and Financial Crimes Services and at Ontario Provincial Police for 8 years. It began as a casual chat, in which Det.-Sgt. Provincial Court Judge Mike Dinkel excluded the confession, concluding she told Calgary police what they wanted to hear. Many people, such as journalist Michelle Lund, have commented that Smyth's soft-spoken interrogations are now textbook examples. Attorney General Merrick Garland on Friday tapped Jack Smith, a longtime federal prosecutor and former head of the Justice Department's public integrity section, as special counsel to oversee the . Republication or distribution of this content is . This is getting beyond my control, all right? The detectives words became hostile, yet his tone remained steady and firm. Director Adam Seelig cast two women playing the parts of Smythand Williams alternating between the roles, and they'llbe joined by a drummer on stage to fillin censored gaps of the transcript. The video begins with Smyth telling Williams why he has been called in to speak with police. Ever been interviewed by the police in a room like this before? Smyth asked. Jim Smith Director of Law Enforcement Relations Chief of Police (Ret. Perry, who previously worked on cases with Smyth, said the OPP investigator used a "classic way of presenting evidence" during the interrogation. ", While Seelig said he and the theatre company have responded to concerns like this, Dafoe said it's a "stockreply. . Okay, um, footwear impressions? Smyth continued. James Smith. With no other evidence against him, Cory Armishaw, 26, was cleared of second-degree murder over the 2006 shaking death of three-month-old Jaydin Lindeman in Guelph, Ont. cause Ive met guys who actually kind of enjoyed the notoriety. Exclusive articles by Conrad Black, Barbara Kay, Rex Murphy and others. The sketch showed a laneway across from a house set at a particular angle to the road, court has seen. Several hours pass by and Smyth makes it increasingly clear there is heavy suspicion surrounding Williams. However, the confession contradicts McClintic's claims at the ongoing trial of Rafferty that she was the one who dealt the fatal blows to the eight-year-old girl. . His body language had slowly shifted from a cocky confidence to distress, defeat, and, ultimately, resignation. 8-Wing TrentonThe official Air Force website for the Canadian Forces Base at Trenton, Ontario. What do four of the world's top body language, behavior, and interrogation e. Thats because the law considers me to be what we refer to as a person in authority. After Jaydin died, from brain injuries consistent with shaking, police also interrogated Kayla, but failed to pursue inconsistencies in her evidence, Judge Langdon wrote. An image of the animal served as the wallpaper on the colonel's BlackBerry. Undercover officers were posted to watch Wilkie Drive, but without results. At some point he had gone back and scratched out The moment and written, Immediately before over top of it.]. this place. Williams was stripped of rank and dismissed from the Canadian Forces. Colonel Russell Williams appears in a Belleville, Ont., courtroom on Oct. 7, 2010, as depicted by a sketch artist. Audience Relations, CBC P.O. Williams unfolded his arms and leaned forward, his interest keenly focused on the photographs before him. your credibility is gone, okay?, Smyth leaned forward and looked down at his cowering adversary, whose mind was clearly swirling as he assessed his options. I hope so, Williams mumbled, his face projecting an unspoken arrogance, as though he was trying to keep from smiling. Williamswas sentenced in October 2010 and is serving two life terms in prison for the murders of Comeau and Lloyd, and additional sentences for 86 other charges. Do you remember what you wouldve done that evening to go to Ottawa for that meeting? When that evidence comes in and that DNA matches, when that phone rings, and somebody knocks on this door. Dafoe grew up with the 27-year-old Belleville resident, who was killed in 2010 by the former commander of CFB Trenton in eastern Ontario. ", "I just want people to know how hurtful this is, how harmful this has been. Van Allen concluded that the prowler posed an increasing danger for a hands on sexual assault.. . Our dealership here in Ottawa says theyre very popular for the Pathfinder, so. "There is nothing about this that speaks art to me," said Terra Dafoe, Jessica Lloyd's childhood friend, who is also a psychologist. He stood staring at the floor as the detective asked two questions that would soon be on the minds of many people. Williams exhaled deeply. The trial into the death of Victoria Stafford has revealed disturbing details about the final hours of the Woodstock, Ont., girl, but it has also shed light on a highly skilled police interrogator. Unlike the interrogation tactics of yesteryear, thered be no swinging lampshades with hot lights, no tired good-cop, bad-cop acts with testosterone-fueled shouting matches, and no pounding fists with rolled-up sleeves. We try not to divulge any information we may have until we feel it becomes necessary, until essentially the interview turns into more of an interrogation.". They look for a way to open up a suspect and to get them to start talking. Well, you start by telling the truth, Smyth replied firmly. On the night of 23 February, he dumped Lloyds body in the woods near Tweed. He had left home later that night, around 8 or 9 p.m., to sleep at the base before flying a crew to California the next morning. Smyth asked him about what kind of feelings he experienced with Jessica, having spent almost twenty-four hours together. The conversation soon took another dramatic shift. Williams said he was in a hurry because he had a sick child at home. He sat up and crossed his arms as he quietly contemplated his next step. Access articles from across Canada with one account. In June 1997 he began working with the OPP, moving to the behavioural sciences section of the force in. "I could see a portion of a garbage bag underneath the rocks," Smyth testified, taking several long pauses as he appeared to compose himself. affairs, he said. .. that contains our DNA. If theres anything that comes up in our interview today, Russell, that you feel you want to talk to a lawyer about, you just let me know.. After thirty seconds of silence, the colonels head started to nod. Share your thoughts and join the conversation in the comments. . . The OPP settled out-of-court with Massicotte in 2015, but as of 2016 her lawsuit against Williams and Harriman was still active. She viewed him as pretty useless and just a placement, and both police and Mr. Armishaw believed she was still in a sexual relationship with Jaydins father. That evidence is all there. . Yeah, no, I understand, Williams interrupted. Corporal James Smith. He grabbed the prints to take a closer look. Smyth abruptly changed the topic again and began discussing swipe access cards that were used on the base. Rafferty has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder, sexual assault causing bodily harm and kidnapping. Canada Famed detective Jim Smyth's interrogation techniques derail murder case OPP interrogator Jim Smyth has a reputation that demands a screenplay. Is there anything you can think of that anybody may have misinterpreted or anything in your history that somebody might say, Russell Williams did this?, Absolutely not. On February 7, Williams was interrogated by OPP investigator Detective Superintendent Jim Smyth and confronted with the evidence of tire tracks and boot prints at Lloyd's home. Perhaps the most flabbergasting of those hints, investigators say, is the euthanizing of Curio, an 18-year-old indoor cat that had been with the officer and his wife, Mary-Elizabeth Harriman, since it was a kitten. The investigation, Smyth said, involved fifty to sixty officers and would end up costing well over $10 million.[6]. In fact, it wasnt even halfway over. The detective explained how DNA profiling had advanced so much that only a tiny sample was now required to determine a match. But the hard drives he had carefully hidden in aluminum air vents in the garage, and a large cache of womens underwear was stashed in an empty computer scanner box that sat amongst unpacked boxes lining the basement wall of their newly built executive home. It was on Feb. 7, at some point during his nine-hour interrogation by the Ontario Provincial Police, that Colonel Russell Williams finally got around to addressing that which had been haunting him. Colonel David Russell Williams was a decoratedair forcepilot and commander at theCanadian Forces Base(CFB) atTrenton,Ontario, when he was arrested in 2010, and charged with the murders of two women, and numerous other sexually related crimes. In custody, and advised by his lawyer to keep silent, Mr. Armishaw was subjected to the same interrogation techniques used on Williams, then one of Canadas top military minds. Readers using BlackBerries and iPhones can As he swaggered into the room, chewing confidently on a wad of gum, Williams was directed to take a seat across from the small tabletop workstation. Driver charged in crashed that injured CTV reporter in Ont. [He then stopped writing and scribbled out the lines he had written.]. On the afternoon of 7 February, Williams went to Ottawa Police headquarters at the request of OPP Detective Sergeant Jim Smyth, who said he had a few loose ends to tie up. Marie-France Comeau, along with 86 other charges. The fact that Smyth calls him "Russell" is significant, said Mendelson, because it puts the detective and Williams on an even playing field. At the heart of the case is the brutal death of the dear little girl a whole country came to know in the spring and summer of 2009, Victoria (Tori) Stafford, The wife of serial sex killer Russell Williams has decided not to seek a stay of a recent court decision rejecting her legal appeal to prevent media coverage of her intended divorce proceedings. I know she loved you very much because she told me she did, again and again. Let me ask you this, Smyth continued. "Its a combination of the two. Both women were asleep when Williams broke in. Unlimited online access to Ottawa Sun and 15 news sites with one account. When prison officials told Simpson, "Don't come back," the former Buffalo Bills star responded, "I don't have any intent," according to Keast.. . "I think in Canada we try to do things properly," said Foord. After the detective had deftly planted the seed in the mind of his now-rattled opponent, he excused himself from the room for a break. In. Elliot Leyton, a Memorial University professor who has authored several studies on serial killers, said Williams "is intelligent enough to know that they had him.". Smyth chuckled and changed the subject again, asking the colonel whether he ever watched the television show CSIas he segued into a discussion about DNA evidence and modern advances in forensic testing procedures. Williams hunches his shoulders. ], You wont believe me, I know, but I am sorry for having taken your daughter from you. Like would it be, uh. Jim Smyth, a veteran investigator, is the other man seen in the video. .. This copy is for your personal non-commercial use only. Williams had pleaded guilty to all 88 charges against him. His interest was working in the violent crimes division. LONDON, ONT. Reg Rackham of Ontario Provincial Police never drew his gun during 26 years of police work. Smyth told the colonel that while he may have been called upon to speak with officers at the base regarding Comeaus murder, or may have spoken with other law enforcement officials about the crimes, he should not feel restricted by any previous comments that he had made to them. With true military precision, Colonel Russell Williams arrived at the Ottawa police headquarters at 3 p.m. and reported for his scheduled interview.