alternative to brooks cambium alternative to brooks cambium

I'm Joseph Brooks and I'm 12 an until recently I found out I'm related to the founder of brooks saddles back from 1700s but no one knows since the family later on split up in 1800s so I find it awesome to be related to this family, Your email address will not be published. The saddle itself is like an opposition to the Brooks C17. This ensures excellent comfort and keeps you in contact with your saddle, rather than bouncing around on rougher surfaces. You can trust Cyclingnews Cyclingnews is part of Future plc, an international media group and leading digital publisher. Its about as comfortable as riding a block of wood so Im going to buy another Swallow and this time keep it for good, even if I sell the bike. I have a city bike from Detroit Bikes, with a Shimano Alpine IG 8 speed. Of course, I wouldnt advise lifting your bike like this but it is almost an inevitability sometimes eg adjusting the position of your loaded touring bike on a moving train. Brooks introduced its natural rubber Cambium saddles a while ago as an instantly comfortable alternative to the legendary perineum patience-testing leather saddles. If you want classic style, performance and elegance, for a 100 and a list weight of just 230 grams you could get the timelessly elegant, performance oriented Selle Italia 1990 Titanium. FREE Shipping +1 colors/patterns. Youre likely to grab the first bit thats there, and thats going to be the handlebars or the saddle. I tested the Brooks Cambium on a Stanforth Skyelander touring bike over the course of a week cycling in Greece. And Selle Royal make zillions of saddles at all price points and sell them all over the world and lots of them are very good. But the combination of hard vulcanised rubber and fat chunks of steel is just.bad for my butt and I suspect it will be for many others. Proofide twice a year. Nothing concrete here, unfortunately. The C17 S, left, and B17 S. In 1888, Brooks England began making leather saddles. |, USD $120.00 In the meantime: Whats your experience with the Brooks Cambium bike saddle? So it is about time to find out what comfort improvements can bring three of the best saddles currently available. My Brooks C17 Cambium All-weather saddle is made from vulcanized natural rubber and according to Brooks it is ready to ride from the first minute. The latest Cambiums get bag loops on the rear frame, too, which is a rare thing these days. Each Cambium saddle is handmade in Italy and features an organic cotton top accentuated by four aluminum rivets: three in the back and one on the nose. Brooks Cambium C17 Special - Black/Black Rubber w/Copper Rivets. 100% inspiration. Foolishly I let the saddles go when I sold the bikes they were fitted to; big mistake. On day 3, the familiar aching in uncomfortable places started about an hour before the end of my cycling day. Dont miss our epic adventures. So when I g. The uniquely flexible, maintenance-free, waterproof top is designed to follow the rider's movements to deliver immediate comfort and ease of use. Brooks Cambium C15 10 My experience of the Brooks cambium saddle was that it was expensive, heavy, uncomfortable, not ideal for rain/bad weather and with at least a bit of a question mark on durability. I found this to be especially true in the more upright position on the Brompton, where I was nearly always planted on my sit bones, but even in a more aggressive position on the road bike I felt the flex take the sting out of the local roads. Ive been experimenting with a few saddles to see if I can find another saddle that works as well. Brooks Cambium is a unique saddle good luck. They come in a couple of trim levels and weights similar to your goal. "name": "Is Brooks cambium good? Frankly, I dont carefully watch weight when it comes to any aspect of my cycling, so I didnt compare the C15s weight against my previous generic Selle Italia. If you're new to the blog, let me start with a quick introduction. . Theres no getting over the fact that Brooks Cambium saddles are pricey, though. Established in 1866, Brooks is a saddle making icon. Privacy Policy. However, when I'm riding it the entire experience is as though I'm floating on the saddle, and it allows me an almost perfect transfer of power to the pedals in any position I'm riding in, from totally upright to down in the drops. Ive now ridden on it (on two different bikes) from Aachen in Germany, over the Swiss alps and into Parma in Italy, a little over 1000km and can confidently say that in my experience the single best thing about the Brooks cambium is the high resale value. SQ Lab 612 Ergowave Active with the softest elastomer is exactly on the same level of comfort in terms of measured vibrations but like I already said, when I was on a longer gravel trip I felt slightly less comfortable on an Ergowave saddle. Perhaps I'm a whinger? The Fen Edge. The fact its always on the bike that Im doing the most distance or roughest rides on is definitely significant, not least because Ive generally got a crate of alternative test saddles to select from, many of which are half the weight. Both the Fabric Scoop and Selle SMP saddles feature traditional elastomer foam padding, although the latter is also covered in black leather or colored microfiber. Any actual hard resources are the shop specific ones that are not open to the public, but I share what I can when appropriate. "@type": "Question", The only challenge? A trio of Cambium colourways inspired by adventure. I do think it looks pretty good on most builds. Hi Dave And the data shows it, The most comfortable saddle in terms of reducing vibrations is Brooks C17. They come in a couple of trim levels and weights similar to your goal. Go with B-17. We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices. I was curious why Numac was still advertised on the Brooks website if it didnt pass the companys quality tests and if its not used to waterproof their saddles. Poor move I say. I felt this colour hinted at the timeless appeal of a classic Brooks, The flexibility of the vulcanised rubber top ensures excellent comfort, and unlike a Brooks leather saddle it doesnt require breaking in, The updated reinforced back plate bears the Brooks logo and has loops for attaching a saddle bag or for other accessories. (LogOut/ Manta Saddle or RelaxIQ seems good but since there is no nose then it might become too dangerous at high speed or busy traffic areas. It obviously bewilders Brooks as well, because none of their website pages currently has a comprehensive list! Made from vulcanized natural rubber . Bath It just feels right from the moment you sit on it and with the softest elastomer, offers a huge amount of comfort (at least for a firm and flat saddle) and encourages you to ride fast. While Brooks gets better every hour you spend on the saddle the SQ Lab (although much less than the standard, non-suspended saddle) starts to bother you slightly. I have bikepacked exclusively on a c17 and it is perfect. fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); In my own view Cambium is utterly horrible. Some, especially longer riders like to change the position on the saddle while riding so a short saddle like this will not work for them but this was not a problem for me. really swish on Schindelhauers cool belt-drive bikes. Bicycle touring is about taking trips via bicycle. Underneath it all, youll find tubular steel rails and a die-cast aluminum structure. Spirit level straight. However, in my experience the textured surface of the saddle LOVES dirt and grot. Nicht mein erster Brooks Sattel, und mit Sicherheit auch nicht mein letzter. Awaiting my C13 (found a new unused second hand at a decent price, couldn't resist). ), A set of resources that you could share (in which, would love to see them! Brooks have been making leather saddles for a long long time. I bought a Brooks Swallow to compliment the build I did of a Classic Raleigh frame. It's NOT soft and offers no cushioning (like the WTB Volt does), but it's surprising more comfortable than you might expect when you're holding the hard rubber unmounted saddle out of the box. But there is also a difference in how those saddles feel after a few hours of riding (at least for me). So there you have it: try the Brooks saddle first and if you will not like it after a few longer rides, then go for an SQ Lab one. I switched to the Brooks b67 and loved it right off the bat. I just couldn't get comfortable. More bike stuff should be easily maintained by the casual user without special tools.On the other hand, the metal sections at each end appear to be held on just by rubber tension and plastic washers. "@type": "Answer", Voer uw trefwoord in Uitgebreid zoeken: Hulp en contact; Huidige taal Nederlands Nederlands . The Cambium line of saddles switches from the traditional Brooks leather construction to a more weather resistant and durable rubber material and the Carved version adds a . Since B67 Imperial was discontinued back in 2013 then there is no other choice but to modify it by yourself if one doesn't want to spend extra 40 for custom/bespoke service, but then there is no more warranty. During this time, I clocked up around 600 kms. The saddle replaced the WTB Volt that the Salsa ships with, which is also a fine saddle, but the Cambium improved the comfort from the first moment of my first ride on it. Brooks C17 is like a flexible shell that you sit on (similarly to todays 3D printed hollow saddles) so it has a very nice dampening effect as well. | Sporting Goods, Cycling, Other Cycling | eBay! In my opinion, the Cambium is a super sharp saddle. BUY THE SADDLE (ORIGINAL OR CARVED): https://amzn.to/3BqYSvCWhen I was looking at buying these saddles I wanted a comparison but didn't find one. Zrecenzowano w Niemczech w dniu 23 maja 2022. Brooks are already well known for their flagship B17 leather saddle, which is almost the de facto standard for long distance cycle tourists around the world. I've not used anything else since. Plus, what the manufacturer advertises, and how it compares to competitors. It was the most apparent when I was testing a Kinekt 2.1 suspension seatpost on the harshest settings I literally felt and hear how it was flexing under my bottom. Brooks England Cambium saddles are hand-crafted using vulcanised natural rubber & organic cotton. Subscribe to our inspirational newsletter. Brooks Cambium is a line of saddles constructed of vulcanized natural rubber and organic cotton canvas, with a thin layer of structural textile added for extra durability and legendary Brooks longevity. "name": "Is a Brooks saddle worth it? Weve put thousands of miles into Cambiums without any obvious signs of wear beyond slight wear fading (think favourite jeans) and as youd hope for the price, theres no creak or frame separation either. Ready to ride for all weathers and roads, the flexibility of a natural rubber top on the simple construction of our cambium saddle has been designed to move with you on the journey. My vibration measurements definitely support my subjective feelings but before we go for the data lets talk about another two contenders. Matching bar tape (or bar grips for non-drop bar bikes) are also available for styling perfection. if you're doing 100 miles, you'll appreciate the extra support of B17. but have removed some value. This is my primary saddle since March and I did more than 2000 km on it so I know its strengths and weaknesses quite well. #5 Durability, maintenance and robustnessThis is a mixed bag. This Brooks c17 review is based on my own personal experiences with the cambium saddle, taking into account past experiences with other saddles. Lightweight alternative to Brooks Cambium C15 carved? I was initially worried about excessive wear and tear on the topit is fabric, after all!but it feels solid and doesnt seem out of line with basic vinyl and foam saddles. Highly recommended for comfort, performance and looks too! I found out that it offers vibration-damping properties similar to Ergowave saddle equipped with the middle elastomer. Still, Id imagine the Cambium lineup will work well for a variety of anatomies, once you discern your width preferences. Cannondale Topstone Carbon Lefty 1 review. The Cambium does so, and in my case has added a real air of class to an otherwise standard-issue, workhorse Brompton. The vulcanised rubber not only removes the many miles of breaking in required on a leather saddle it also makes the Cambium totally weatherproof. Still, some complain that the fabric on its nose wears prematurely, which isnt something Ive experienced so far. comfortable like no other, weight bedamned, bouncy seatpost installed too. I very much approve of their FAQs and maintenance tips on the website which tell you how to maintain the saddle yourself, and that it can all be done by hand, without special tools or mechanical aptitude props to Brooks for that. Brooks England Cambium C15 All Weather Bike Saddle CARVED 140MM BLACK ! You are using an out of date browser. Q36.5 Level 3 base layer review: seamless long sleeve performance. A website about bikes, cycling, urban riding, cycle touring and fixies. It's not a season-ender by any means, but it would be nice to find a good . For the first couple of days, the saddle seemed fine, and I noticed no issues at all. This was nothing to get concerned about, as it happens on every tour even with the best saddle in the world. : Weatherproof CAMBIUM C19 CARVED ALL WEATHER90. The rubber used to make the saddle flex exceptionally well, which helps to recreate the famous slung hammock-style flexibility of Brookss leather seats. This will be a less pronounced curve - Scratch M5 PAS | Prologo, Powered by Discourse, best viewed with JavaScript enabled. Non-leather saddle A vegan alternative! Is it worth the investment, or should you explore seats from another manufacturer? Brooks England Cambium saddles are made from vulcanized natural rubber & the finest quality organic cotton, enjoy a more comfortable ride every time. With a history dating back over 100 years, few other cycling products have been field tested for so long by so many people! Whether you're going out for the weekend or cycling across continents, bicycletouring is a community of individuals who share this passion. I got a new replacement C17 from Brookes yesterday after the cover of first one started to break at the back of the nosepiece and I moaned at em. The fabric element gives just enough grip to stop you sliding about and theyre not sweaty either. Winkelen op rubriek. Notify me of follow-up comments by email. P.S. The Cambium C19 saddle adds almost another inch to its width, which Brooks advertises makes it ideal for touring, city riding, and a more upright seated position. In fact, the seat felt almost wooden when sitting on it! #8 Brooks of..England Italy?Brooks strongly market their England connection, even though they have been owned by Selle Royal of Italy since 2002. While most saddles are either leather or cushioned plastic, the Cambium uses an Italian vulcanized rubber . JavaScript is disabled. But, if youre willing to splurge, I think the Cambium could deliver a solid level of value. Our lightest racing saddle for top performance, Our lightest racing saddle with pressure relief, A sport saddle for gravel, road and fast touring, A hole for pressure relief and additional flex, Naturally flexible rubber that moves with you, Premium details and flexible performance combined. |, f/4/1/0/f410d1be18e3f3c25fcf62afafd028dddc8bda39_Brooks_Cambium_All_Weather_C17_01.jpg, Exceptional comfort, classy looks, heritage, Not for pure racers due to weight and flexibility, How to set the saddle height on your bike, The C17 comes in three finishes: black, octane (blue) and this stunning bronze/orange. Had some old no-name thick leather saddle years ago with Lycett type web of springs underneath it. Wanted - Specialized Tarmac Elite Fork (Or Equivalent). NIce they replaced it, sad they degraded it. Ready to ride for all weathers and roads, the flexibility of a natural rubber top on the simple construction of our cambium saddle has been designed to move with you on the journey. Visit our corporate site (opens in new tab). Free delivery for many products! Shop now! However, it is quite heavy compared to its more modern counterparts. The Cambium bike saddle range is a product by Brooks England, who are probably most well known for their traditional leather saddle range. Find out more about how we test. "text": "The Brooks Cambium C17 compares favorably to most high-quality aftermarket saddles. (function(d, s, id) { The length of time they took to address this compared to many other retailers seems to lack self-respect for the heritage of the company and the core customer base that has kept them in business since 1866. But Brooks saddles, especially leather ones are also known from the adaptation time that is needed to make the saddle fit your particular bottom. You can find further information on how we treat your personal information and how to exercise your rights inside our. 5MV-43b - Brooks C17 Cambium Carve Review: one year on.-----Just over a year ago I suffered the worst saddle sore that I hav. Hi Pierrox - Thanks so much for your feedback, and for additional details about the nose issue. Shimano S-Phyre RC903 review: can you spot what's new? Competing High-End Bike Saddles, My Bottom Line About the Brooks Cambium Saddle. However, SA saddles are adjustable via a screw, which can help ensure its leather is always correctly tensioned. Numac remained advertised on the Brooks website as of publishing. $217.53 $ 217. Unsurprisingly, the C15 is meaningfully wider than any of my previous saddles and based on my riding preferences, Im glad I didnt go with a broader C17 or C19 model. Brexit related difficulties are hardly their own making, and the 135 is related to taxes and tariffs it is true, but thousands of other retailers were in a similar position and were able to make the necessary adjustments far quicker and without a flat-footed block on sales to what could/should be considered their home market. I chose it based on its width being basically the same (153mm v 155mm) of my Specialized Romin Evo Pro; a saddle that was chosen (with guidance) as suiting my arse and riding profile. Please feel free to share this post, and pin this Brooks Cambium c17 all weather review for later. The Radavist. Had an opportunity to try out B67s and it was putting too much pressure on the perineum even in an upright position. I had a long inner debate about this because I really liked the feel of an SQ Lab 612 Ergovawe Active saddle. If you have registered to receive our newsletter or, for any reason, you have provided us with your personal information, this merger will not affect the treatment of your data and your rights under the Reg. The first one same as yours -greyish and canvas-topped, silver rivets, shiny metal body and rails.. So for off road or mucky adventures, or even for a low maintenance around-town bike I would again not recommend Cambiums. That is true though of course it is also true of, like, 98% of all the other saddles in existence. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Hi, I'm Dave, and I've been creating helpful travel guides and itineraries for independent travelers on Dave's Travel Pages since 2005. Numac was supposed to be a waterproofing spray. Bontrager Verse Comp Bike Saddle | Trek Bikes (AU), That WTB saddle that comes stock with most MTBs, Working in the industry (I think I saw that youre at a shop? In my opinion, whilst the Brooks Cambium C17 is arguably the best non-leather saddle for long-distance cycling on the market, it is still inferior to a good leather bicycle saddle. They are also 1 really really heavy and 2 renowned for needing lots of maintenance and not dealing well with being left out in the rain which is a pretty major downside for basically any outdoors product sold in the UK/German/Dutch markets. I felt this colour hinted at the timeless appeal of a classic Brooks . The rubber itself is hard and essentially unpadded, so it is springy but not squishy. Brooks has been making leather bicycle saddles since the 19th century and its products are the stuff of legend. The new one a glossy woven-looking top, black rivets. If you don't want to use leather for whatever reasons, again, this makes a great choice. The go-to for any luxury, restoration or comfort build. However, the Selle SMP weighs less than half that of the Brooks Cambium or Selle Anatomica, if youre looking to shave as much weight as possible from your setup. SummaryMaybe its the fact that the Cambium tortured my bum for 1000km across Europe, or perhaps I just hate that I fell for the hype of a big name and found it lacking. Find the most comfortable gravel bike and bike parts. Brooks Cambium saddles also come with two-year warranties, whereas Selle Anatomica offers one-year warranties. Rode a B17 for quite a long time, now have a C17 on my touring/gravel bike. So in future, instead of buying an Italian saddle from a German website despite them being from England, Ill stick to one of my beloved Selle Italia saddles which I think are proudly made in Taiwan. Our most sustainable C17 bike saddle to date. And after comfort, if youre considering a Brooks saddle, style points are probably on your agenda. When it comes to bike touring, Brooks have become the gold standard when it comes to what saddle to use. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); their own marketing guff and the pretty pictures on their website. Ive been waiting for the Cambium to wear in but its no better than than day I fitted it so Ive come to the conclusion that its never going to happen. I gave two a fair trial but could not find a width or position that didnt hurt after only a few miles. For the best experience on our site, be sure to turn on Javascript in your browser. So: I now have a new cover retaining all the metalwork from the old. The middle section acts like a bouncy hammock while the nose and the tail of the saddle are, basically, rock solid. Brooks Cambium Saddles C17 Octane. As a result, this review does not include any experiences riding with the C17 Cambium in the rain. What Are the Differences Between Each Brooks Cambium Model? 5,0 z 5 gwiazdek Brooks Cambium C17. Supple tires shootout: 6 contenders in the test, Quick review: Gore Windstopper C3 jacket and Shimano SH-MW501 shoes, bikelab_TEST: improving comfort by lowering air pressure. And at this price, its not something you want buy and then dislike.Nevertheless, there are many people for whom these saddles do seem to work well and if thats you, great. Keep in mind that anyone's review is just a combination of their experiences. If you're into long distance cycling or bike touring, you're going to spend a lot of time in the saddle. In this Brooks Cambium review, I'll take a look at their vegan' alternative, and see if it's in the same league. The original Cambiums exposed that cotton top to the elements, so the addition of a weatherproof nylon coating here is a welcome one, particularly when it comes to commuting. My long distance cycling trips have included cycling from England to Cape Town, and Alaska to Argentina. Limited-edition saddle celebrating classic British brands. Hi Dan - Thanks for your feedback! Feel the comfort & durability in all locations and weathers. #2 StyleOk fine. And in fairness, their leather saddles are still made in England even though they may be processed/dispatched from Italy. Ive tried this stunning Bronze/Orange C17 on both my everyday road bike as well as my folding bike, to get a feel for how it performs in all circumstances. Heavy but smoothly supportive comfort and timeless style like no other saddle. No idea how it would compare to a swallow though. Greek Island Hopping | Greece Travel Itineraries | Bicycle Touring. Over extended use this could become an issue, but 1000km was not enough to conclusively say so. for shorter rides the c17 has the advantage. I might even be tempted to say the Fabric Range are the best of the lot, given their huge range you can select one for your sit bone width, spine flexibility, riding position, colour and wallet (more expensive parts of the Fabric range = less weight).The one function that the Brooks has which is really neat, is the loops on the back of the saddle for saddlebags. Choose a blog page for more travel inspiration and practical tips and insights: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Be warned, theyll be baby-bog yellow. I'm considering a rain cover like so, but I'm not sure how long that would last before it . Have Brooks come up with a perfect non-leather saddlefor bicycle touring? Comparatively, the Cambium C13 boasts a continuous carbon rail and all-black aluminum rivets that reduces its weight by 150 grams. Heres how it works. I have got Brooks Flyer Imperial at the moment. ", #7 They eat my shorts Like Bart Simpsons nemeses, the Cambium seems to have engaged in an unending binge for eating the garments of my lower half. For full disclosure, Ive been riding Brooks leather saddles since the early '90s so theres some personal ischial bone investment in the brand and Ive been on an original Cambium since it first launched. The B17 is undoubtedly more comfortable, and seems to virtually 'disappear' while you ride it, it's that good. The metal parts feel very solid (no doubt contributing to the weight). There is a small weight penalty over a performance saddle due to the C17s steel rails, and you might not want a Cambium on your full-on race bike there is surely a trade-off in power for this much comfort but for an endurance or touring bike, commuter or winter trainer this is a perfect saddle when it comes to performance and looks. } Because I was worried about getting the Natural Cambium versions top dirty, I chose to order the black model with vulcanized natural rubber underside and bare steel rails. Brooks own carbon fibre Cambium (the C13) is a whopping 175 and still 285g in its lightest carved option.And if you really wanted the whole British thing, you can get our very own CSC Union Jack saddles at 265g (coming soon, I hope).Ive ridden all of these options except the Fizik and while they all have benefits and drawbacks of their own, I would choose any of them for any ride over the Brooks. So far, Ive logged just 180 miles on my Cambium. Fixed gear riders often lift the bike by the saddle to re-orient the cranks at traffic lights, so this might give you cause to re-consider the Brooks if youre on a coaster brake or fixie set-up. Brooks England S.r.l. A trio of Cambium colourways inspired by adventure. Most saddles weigh about 200-220 grams, so I could save nearly half a pound of bike weight if I could find a good substitute. Seems fairly comfortable in terms of correct pressure distribution, the only thing is: the metal frame seems to be a bit too narrow for me since it's pressing too much on the sit bones (handlebars at the same hight). Whether this was an Italian or a British person isnt known but is contrary to their ethos as cultivated in their absurd advertising copywriting. My overall rating for this saddle after my bike tour and a few rides more is 7/10. It allows for a side to side movement but the middle of the saddle is not suspended at all so when you combine it whit quite flat surface of the saddle you realize that there is still a fair amount of energy going to your bottom from hitting a bigger bumps. JavaScript seems to be disabled in your browser. Tern Eclipse P20 / Link C7 Tern folding bikes in-depth review Common Sense Cycles. Brooks will not replace as it is out of warranty.